Hey, fellow TV lovers! Let’s talk about Elizabeth Dutton from Paramount+’s rugged Western 1923. She has a strong desire to become a mother, yet she encounters significant challenges! In Season 1, a devastating miscarriage leaves her and the Dutton family questioning whether having children is a permanent decision. However, in Season 2, episode 4, Dr. Steven Miller unexpectedly reveals that she is pregnant! That bombshell keeps her glued to Jack Dutton and his Montana crew instead of packing for Boston. Then, bam—the Season 2 finale flips everything. Jack’s death rocks her world, and now she’s rethinking her life at the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch. What does that mean for her little one? At TV Acute, we’re hooked on finding out!
Elizabeth’s Rocky Road to Motherhood
Elizabeth Dutton, originally Elizabeth Strafford, steps into the Dutton family with big dreams and a fierce spirit. She marries Jack Dutton, the great-nephew of Jacob Dutton (Harrison Ford), in 1923’s first season. But life on the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch isn’t kind. In Season 1, she suffers a devastating miscarriage that leaves her and Jack questioning if kids are even in their future. It’s a tough blow, and you can feel the weight of it through the screen.
Fast forward to Season 2, episode 4—hope sparks again! Dr. Steven Miller confirms Elizabeth’s pregnancy, completely upending her world in the most positive way. This news even convinces her to stick with Jack and the Duttons in Montana instead of bolting to Boston like she’d planned. For a minute, it looks like things might finally go her way. But if you’ve watched the Season 2 finale, you know the happiness doesn’t last long. Jack’s sudden death changes everything, and now Elizabeth’s future—and her baby’s—is up in the air.
WILL THERE BE A 1923 SEASON 3? LATEST UPDATES AND WHAT TO EXPECT NEXT
Why Leaving the Ranch Could Save Her Baby
The death of Jack in the Season 2 finale deeply affects Elizabeth. Upon Spencer Dutton’s return to the ranch without Jack, she discovers his body in the woods, fulfilling her deepest fears. After his funeral, she’s done with the Duttons. Why stick around when the man she loved is gone? She’s put her life on the line too many times for this family—facing danger from both nature and enemies—and Jack’s death is the final straw. Boston’s calling her name again, and this time, she’s ready to go.
Here’s the thing: leaving Montana might be the smartest move for Elizabeth and her unborn child. Life on the ranch is brutal—think shootouts, harsh weather, and constant stress. None of that’s good for a pregnant woman, especially one who’s already lost a baby. By heading to Boston, she’s ditching the chaos for a fresh start. No more dodging bullets or praying the next storm doesn’t wipe them out—she can focus on keeping herself and her little one safe.
Plus, Boston’s got top-notch doctors and hospitals. Elizabeth, having experienced a miscarriage, understands the challenges of this pregnancy. Elizabeth requires the highest quality of care to prevent the loss of this unborn child. Back at the ranch, help’s limited—Dr. Miller’s great, but if an emergency hits, she’d either wait for him or risk a dangerous trip to Bozeman. In Boston, she has immediate access to medical assistance. It’s easy to understand how this move could significantly impact her and her child’s survival.
Does Elizabeth’s Baby Show Up in Yellowstone?
So, let’s say Elizabeth makes it to Boston and gives birth—does her kid ever show up in Yellowstone? Spoiler: Nope, not as far as we know. The Dutton family tree in Yellowstone doesn’t mention Elizabeth and Jack’s child, which makes sense if you think about it. When she leaves the ranch, she’s cutting ties with the Duttons for good. She’s not looking back, and that likely means her baby grows up far from Montana and the family’s messy legacy.
Elizabeth’s all about starting over after Jack’s death. She’s not tied to the ranch anymore, so why would she send her kid back to that world? Her focus is on building a new life, not holding onto the past. That’s why her child doesn’t seem to play a role in Yellowstone’s present-day story with John Dutton III and his crew.
But wait—there’s more to chew on. In the Season 2 finale, Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren) hints at Elizabeth remarrying someday. Elizabeth brushes it off, but it’s not a crazy idea. She’s young, strong, and practical—she’s already shown she’ll put her own well-being first, like when she almost left Jack before finding out she was pregnant. After mourning Jack, she might meet someone new in Boston. If she does, her kid could grow up with a stepdad, completely disconnected from the Dutton name. That’d explain why we don’t see them in Yellowstone.
Could Her Child Pop Up in a Spin-Off?
Here’s where the fun begins—Taylor Sheridan, the mastermind behind 1923 and Yellowstone, enjoys introducing unexpected twists. While Elizabeth’s baby might not be in Yellowstone, there’s a chance we’ll meet them elsewhere. Enter The Madison, an upcoming Yellowstone spin-off set to introduce the McIntosh family from New York City. Boston’s not far from NYC, right? It’s not a stretch to think Elizabeth could settle nearby after leaving Montana.
Maybe her son or daughter ends up tied to the McIntosh crew. Sheridan’s known for weaving intricate family connections across his shows—just look at how 1883 and 1923 link to Yellowstone. If Elizabeth’s kid grows up in the Northeast, they could easily cross paths with this new family. It’s all speculation for now, but it’s a juicy possibility that keeps us guessing about her baby’s fate.
What’s Next for Elizabeth in ‘1923’?
Elizabeth’s story is far from over. Season 2, commencing on February 23, 2025, has already presented eight captivating episodes, prominently featuring Elizabeth’s pregnancy. Michelle Randolph has teased that this season brings “really great” twists, especially as Elizabeth deals with Jack’s death and her new reality. Losing her husband is tough, but finding out she’s pregnant again gives her a glimmer of hope. Will she make it to Boston? Will her baby survive? We’re rooting for her, and TV Acute will be watching every step of the way.
Her journey also ties into the bigger Dutton saga. 1923 bridges 1883 and Yellowstone, showing how the family fought to hold onto their land through tough times like Prohibition and the Great Depression. Elizabeth and Jack’s story adds a personal layer to that legacy—even if their kid doesn’t show up later, their struggles shape the Duttons’ history.
Do you have any theories about her kid’s future? Drop them below—I’d love to hear what you think!
Read More: 1923 SEASON 2: SPENCER AND ALEXANDRA’S SON NAME REVEALED
