A new face at Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital usually means drama is around the corner—and this week’s GREY’S ANATOMY didn’t disappoint. Titled “LOVE IN THE ICE AGE,” the episode brings an infamous, so-called surgical legend, Dr. Joseph Chase (played by Craig Bierko), into the mix. While Bailey is thrilled to have him visit, others—like Webber and especially Simone—are far less impressed. But the real trouble begins when Chase is tasked with saving a life… and instead, shows everyone exactly why he’s not the miracle worker he claims to be.
Here’s what went down in this action-packed and emotional episode of GREY’S ANATOMY Season 21.
MEET DR. JOSEPH CHASE: A LEGEND OR A FRAUD?
The buzz at Grey Sloan is palpable when Dr. Joseph Chase arrives. Known for his perfect surgical success rate and revolutionary clinical trial, Chase is idolized by many—including Bailey (Chandra Wilson), who sees him as a genius. But for Simone Griffith (Alexis Floyd), his arrival brings back a wave of discomfort. Back in Baltimore, she had worked under Chase, only to be fired for advocating for a Black patient he’d ignored. Now, she’s forced to scrub in with him again on a high-stakes pancreatic cancer case—one that hits close to home.
Dr. Chase’s patient this time is Gabby, a young Black woman diagnosed with an aggressive and rare form of pancreatic adenocarcinoma. Webber (James Pickens Jr.) had already deemed the tumor inoperable, but Chase insists it’s not the patient—it’s the surgeon. He believes his technique can save her, though his arrogance sets off alarm bells for both Webber and Simone.
A SILENT STRUGGLE AND A DANGEROUS SURGERY
Despite Simone’s deep misgivings, she doesn’t warn Bailey about Chase. Instead, she keeps quiet—perhaps out of fear, perhaps out of professionalism—while reassuring Gabby’s mother about Chase’s skills. But that silence will have consequences.
In the operating room, the truth about Chase’s perfect record becomes horrifyingly clear. As soon as the surgery becomes more complicated than expected and he discovers the tumor has breached the arterial wall, Chase decides to quit mid-procedure. He intends to patch Gabby up and let her die, rather than risk a failure that would tarnish his spotless record.
Bailey is furious and refuses to let it happen. In a dramatic moment, she orders Chase out of the OR and steps up herself to take over. Working with Simone and Lucas Adams (Niko Terho), she uses a complex vein graft technique to stabilize Gabby and successfully completes the surgery. Chase’s ego is exposed, and Bailey is left heartbroken that she ever trusted him. “There’s the door,” she tells him, disgusted.
As Chase slinks out, Simone attempts to confront him, but he brushes her off with a smug comment—insulting both her and Bailey on his way out. But Simone gets the last word, acknowledging that everything she’s been through led her to Grey Sloan: “I ended up in the right place.”
TEDDY AND OWEN REEVALUATE THEIR OPEN MARRIAGE
While Bailey and Simone battle surgical betrayal, Teddy Altman (Kim Raver) is dealing with personal upheaval. After giving Owen Hunt (Kevin McKidd) the green light to explore an open marriage, she finds herself unable to follow through. Last week, Teddy backed out of a hookup with Dr. Beckman, but Owen had no problem rekindling things with his childhood friend, Nora.
In this episode, Teddy finally admits what’s been clear all along—she doesn’t want an open marriage. Owen agrees, saying he feels the same. Whether they can truly rebuild trust remains to be seen, but the first steps toward reconciliation have finally been taken.
Meanwhile, Teddy also finds herself wrestling with authority issues at the hospital. Ben Warren (Jason George) continues his campaign to get back in her good graces after disobeying her during the heatwave incident. He takes the radical approach of actually apologizing—a rare sight in this world—and while it may not fix everything overnight, it’s a start.
MUST READ: GREY’S ANATOMY (DON’T YOU, FORGET ABOUT ME) RECAP: SEASON 21 EPISODE 13 EXPLAINED
BLUE’S WAKE-UP CALL
Still reeling from his breakup with Molly, Benson “Blue” Kwan (Harry Shum Jr.) is not exactly thriving. He’s sulking, downing energy drinks, and acting out at work. Link (Chris Carmack), tired of Blue’s moody attitude, assigns him to a case involving a patient named Jack.
Jack’s backstory is peak Grey’s Anatomy tragedy. After losing his brother—an adventure-seeker—in a fatal accident, Jack has spent the last two years traveling to all the places his brother never got to visit. In the process, he’s pushed his body to its limits and now faces a potential amputation.
As Blue listens to Jack’s story, he finds himself shaken out of his funk. Instead of surgery, the doctors find a way to save Jack’s leg. And Blue takes it one step further—setting Jack up with a virtual reality headset so he can “travel” while recovering. It’s a small but meaningful gesture, and while Blue isn’t fully over Molly, he seems ready to start healing.
A LOVE STORY GONE WRONG
Elsewhere in the hospital, Teddy and Owen treat Brendan, a man who falls on an icepick after briefly meeting a woman he believes is his soulmate. After 20 minutes of conversation, Brendan is convinced it’s true love—and when the surgeons track down the mystery woman and bring her to him, he literally sits up to see her… driving the icepick further into his chest.
Brendan dies on the operating table, and the tragic outcome is made worse by the fact that it could have been avoided. The doctors’ decision to reunite Brendan with the woman—though well-meaning—ultimately cost him his life. It’s a painful lesson in boundaries and timing, and a stark reminder that not every patient can be saved.
HOPE ON THE HORIZON FOR ADAMS
As the dust settles from the dramatic surgeries, there’s a quieter development between Adams and Webber. Still in his intern limbo, Adams has been desperate to earn a second chance. Though Webber originally benched him, he finally seems to soften, even pulling out some vintage VHS tapes of his old surgeries for Adams to study.
By the end of the episode, Webber hints that he’s open to advocating for Adams to rejoin the residency program—especially after Adams helped save Gabby. It’s a small but significant step toward redemption for a character who’s spent the season trying to prove himself.
“LOVE IN THE ICE AGE” tackled heavy themes of trust, accountability, and redemption. From Bailey’s heartbreak to Simone’s moment of vindication, from Teddy’s marriage struggles to Blue’s emotional awakening, the episode offered both surgical drama and personal growth.
As always, Grey Sloan’s halls echoed with heartbreak, hope, and the promise of new beginnings.
Don’t miss out on the latest medical miracles and emotional moments — keep visiting tvacute.com for more GREY’S ANATOMY news, updates, and recaps.
Greys Anatomy Season 20 Episode 9 Recap: Maggie Winston Breaks Up & Catherine Fires Teddy
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 8 “Blood, Sweat and Tears” Preview
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 7 Recap
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 6 – [Preview] Dr. Weber’s Condition
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 5 Recap
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 4: Dr. Arizona Robbins Returns
Grey’s Anatomy Season 20 Episode 2 Recap: “Keep the Family Close”
