THEM: THE SCARE EPISODE 1 RECAP: WHAT HAPPENED IN “ARE YOU SCARED”?

THEM on Prime Video is back with a scary new season called THEM: The Scare. The show is set in the 1990s and follows Deborah Ayorinde‘s character, LAPD officer Dawn Reeve, as she looks into a string of horrible murders. Dawn is now a detective and has a teenage son named Kel (Joshua J. Williams) and a loving mother named Athena. She has to figure out how foster mother Bernice Mott (Cindi Davis) died after being found bent over and pushed under a sink cabinet. There is broken glass, a broken clock, and cleaning materials all over the hallway at the crime scene, which looks very scary.

Even though Dawn was given the case, Detective Ronald McKinney (Jeremy Bobb) takes charge because of a mistake she made in the Southside Slayer case. Dawn gets angry at McKinney for closing cases quickly and not doing a good job. McKinney wrongly blames Malcolm (Deion Smith), the boy who reported the murder, for it, saying that Malcolm must have killed her because Mott was so mean to him. When Dawn sees Malcolm in tears, she tells him to hire a lawyer.

At the same time, Edmund Gaines (Luke James), an actor who is having a hard time and works at an arcade, has trouble at his audition for a gangster part because he is quiet. Edmund also has love for Rhonda (Tamika Shannon), the agency’s secretary, with whom he gets along well. Edmund’s dreams are dashed, though, when he sees Rhonda say goodbye to the cameraman with love.

As Dawn enjoys her birthday with her family, her personal life and work life are mixed together. Athena’s declining motor skills and Dawn’s ex-boyfriend’s constant attempts to get in touch with her make things more tense. Strange things are still happening because the lights are flickering in the kitchen and garage while the birthday dinner is going on.

When Rhonda takes her son Kenny (Ace Tucker) to the playground, Edmund and she have a moment of getting close. Rhonda is moved by Edmund’s kindness and offers to help him find a part by reading scripts for him. For Malcolm’s sister Kia (Hattie Hoskins), a flashback shows Bernice’s fear of men, which is what made her group the foster kids to watch TV so she wouldn’t fall asleep. Since Kia was awake during the attack, she saw the man break Bernice Mott’s bones.

Still more flashing lights bother Athena (Pam Grier) at the Reeves’ house. She is cutting carrots when she hears Bernice scream. Kel is busy with his drums upstairs at the same time. When Dawn gets home, she finds them both asleep and starts studying the case. As she tries to imagine herself in the victim’s place under the sink cabinet while listening to the crime scene recording, the sound starts to shake, and at the end, there is a scary question: “Are you scared?”

Coming soon: more THEM: The Scare news, sneak peeks, and reviews at tvacute.com.

IS THEM (2021) ON AMAZON BASED ON A TRUE STORY?
THEM: THE SCARE EPISODE 2 RECAP

Related Articles

Olivia Wilson
Olivia Wilsonhttps://www.tvacute.com/
Olivia Wilson is the senior news writer for TV Acute. She spends too much money on collectables and is enamored with movies, comics, and television series. She loves binge-watching and can spend hours talking about movies and TV shows. She can immerse herself into a good story no matter the genre or form and only come out from it when she's had her fill. When she's not writing, she's probably cooking or exploring new places. You can follow her daily exploits on Twitter and Facebook.

Latest News

netflix the life list review

The Life List Review: Sofia Carson Steals the Show in Netflix’s 2025 Gem

0
"The Life List," a comedy-drama film that blends elements of romance, family dynamics, and personal growth. Released on March 28, 2025, it’s streaming on...

THE LIFE LIST FILMING LOCATIONS (2025): WHERE WAS THE NETFLIX MOVIE FILMED?

0
People will love Netflix's new romantic comedy-drama The Life List because it's a heartwarming story about finding yourself.  The movie is based on a...
Is Hulu’s Mid-Century Modern Based on a True Story

Mid-Century Modern on Hulu: True Story or Fiction? Uncover the Truth!

0
Mid-Century Modern is a new comedy series that premiered today, March 28, 2025, on Hulu, with all 10 episodes available to stream. Created by...
The Life List

IS THE LIFE LIST A TRUE STORY? THE REAL INSPIRATION BEHIND NETFLIX’S FILM

0
Life often throws us curveballs when we least expect them and takes us down paths we never thought possible.  This is exactly what happens...
Forrest Fenn’s Grandson 'Shiloh Old'

Shiloh Old Now: Where Is Forrest Fenn’s Grandson After the Treasure Hunt Chaos?

0
If you’ve been hooked on Netflix’s Gold & Greed: The Hunt for Fenn’s Treasure, you’ve probably spotted Shiloh Old popping up in the docuseries....